Party Like It’s 1929: Killer Party Favors for a 1920s Murder Mystery Night

What’s a night of jazz, champagne, and secret scandals without a little something to send your guests home with? Whether you’re hosting a glamorous Gatsby-style soirée or a smoky speakeasy murder mystery (like our game, Murder at the Manor!), party favors are a fabulous way to thank your guests—and keep the Roaring Twenties vibe going long after the killer’s been revealed. Here are some party favor ideas that are perfect for both suspects and sleuths!

🍾 1. Mini Bottles of “Bathtub Gin” or Champagne

Nothing says “Prohibition chic” like a tiny bottle of booze. Wrap them in kraft paper or decorate with faux bootlegging or themed labels for that extra secret stash vibe.

🎭 2. Feather Headbands or Fedoras

Great as favors and props! Flapper accessories or classic mobster fedoras help guests stay in character and give them a wearable souvenir from the night.

🍸 3. Cocktail Stirrers

Elegant, gold, or art deco-inspired cocktail stirrers are the perfect favor for guests who love a classy drink. Bundle with a mini recipe card for a signature 1920s cocktail!

📖 4. Vintage-Style Bookmarks

A nod to the literary lounges and smoky salons of the era—bookmarks with quotes from The Great Gatsby or other 1920s literature make thoughtful, theme-fitting favors.

🔫 5. Toy Gun (for the Guys) & Pearl Necklace (for the Gals)

Lean into the mobster-and-flapper aesthetic with simple, affordable props, like a pearl necklace or an inflatable tommy gun, guests can wear or wave during the game. They also double as hilarious photo booth fun!

🧯 6. Matchbooks

Classic and timeless—personalized matchbooks with your party name or a cheeky 1920s quote make a simple yet stylish gift.

🥂 7. Art Deco Drink Coasters

Send guests home with coasters featuring glamorous gold-on-black geometric patterns. Functional and fabulous.

🎲 8. Playing Cards

Give guests something to gamble with (legally, of course). A nod to hidden card tables and smoky speakeasies.

The 1920s were all about style, sparkle, and spectacle—and your party favors should be no exception. Whether you go classy, clever, or just plain fun, a thoughtful favor is the perfect final touch to your murder mystery night. After all, a guest who just solved a high-society homicide deserves more than just applause—give them a little treasure to remember it by!