Holiday Costume Awards to Add to Your Mystery Party

An ugly sweater party with a killer twist deserves more than just participation trophies. When guests show up in full costume for your murder mystery game, it’s the perfect opportunity to reward their creativity, character commitment, and subtle (or not-so-subtle) nods to foul play.

Here are some holiday-themed award categories that will keep guests laughing, roleplaying, and snapping selfies all night long:

1. Most Suspicious Sweater

This award goes to the guest whose ugly sweater looks like it could double as a disguise — or hide a deadly weapon. Bonus points for ominous holiday accessories like fake blood stains, mysterious bulges in stocking pockets, or snowflakes with a sinister sparkle.

2. Best Festive Faker

This one’s for the character who seems the most cheerful and full of holiday spirit… but might actually be hiding something. Did their smile look a little forced? Were their compliments oddly specific? If someone’s a little too jolly, they might just be the killer.

3. Most Likely to Kill Under the Mistletoe

Equal parts romantic and dangerous, this award goes to the guest who oozes charm — but raises everyone’s suspicions. Think sultry looks, mistletoe props, and a mysterious backstory filled with broken hearts and holiday betrayal.

4. Deadliest Holiday Accessory

From a “poisoned” candy cane to a stocking that looks like it’s stuffed with more than just coal, give this award to the guest whose accessory could double as a murder weapon. The more dramatic (and hilarious), the better.

5. Best Use of Clues in Costume

If your guests know their characters ahead of time, encourage them to incorporate clues or secrets into their outfits. Maybe their sweater pattern includes a key motif. Maybe their elf hat hides a damning letter. Award the best hidden message or plot twist sewn right into their look.

6. Coldest Character

Not everyone’s here to make merry. This award is for the grumpiest guest with the iciest glare and sharpest tongue — you know, the one everyone suspects even when they’re not guilty.

Tips for Hosting the Awards:

• Hand out themed mini-trophies, ornaments, or printed certificates.

• Let the host choose winners, or allow guests to vote anonymously.

• Present awards after the mystery is solved for a fun wrap-up moment.

A little recognition goes a long way in encouraging full-costume commitment, and these awards will only add to the festive fun and photo ops at your murder mystery party.