Search

Death by Chocolate: Menu

Skills Murder Mysteries
May 19
2 min read

Planning a murder mystery dinner party this Valentine's Day? Sink your teeth into the ultimate Death by Chocolate menu, an indulgent, romantic, and slightly sinister spread that will delight your guests as much as the plot twists. This curated selection of recipes uses chocolate in unexpected ways, turning your dinner into a decadent affair full of flavor, intrigue, and love (or betrayal).

Close-up of broken dark chocolate pieces on a white surface, showcasing rich brown color and sharp, jagged edges. Moods of indulgence.

Bacon-wrapped dates secured with toothpicks on white parchment, showcasing a glossy texture with brown and maroon hues. — Photo Courtesy of Ambitious Kitchen

Appetizers to Die For

Bacon-Wrapped Dark Chocolate & Goat Cheese Stuffed Dates

Sweet, salty, creamy, and rich, these dates are wrapped in crispy bacon and filled with dark chocolate and tangy goat cheese. They're a killer way to start your evening.🔗 Get the recipe

Chocolate Sea Salt Crostini

Crispy crostini topped with a swipe of dark chocolate, a sprinkle of sea salt, and maybe a hint of olive oil. Elegant, easy, and oh-so-chic.🔗 Watch how to make it

Plate with sliced steak, tortillas, and salad with avocado and radish. Fork in background. Warm, inviting mood. — Photo Courtesy of Punchfork

Entrées with a Sinister Twist

Chocolate-Chipotle Sirloin Steak

A bold main course where rich cocoa meets smoky chipotle for a perfectly seared steak with depth and drama. 🔗 Get the recipe

Mozzarella Strawberry Salad with Chocolate Vinaigrette

Fresh, fruity, and unexpected—this salad delivers a hint of sweetness with a dark chocolate vinaigrette dressing. 🔗 Get the recipe

Three glasses of chocolate parfait with layers of whipped cream and crumbled cookies on a marble tray, set against a neutral background. — Photo Courtesy of Olives + Thyme

Desserts Worth Killing For

Death by Chocolate Cake

A show-stopping multi-layer cake filled with ganache, it's rich, dramatic, and impossible to ignore. 🔗 Get the recipe

Chocolate Mousse Parfaits

Layers of velvety mousse and whipped cream topped with cookie crumbles—because even murder can be classy. 🔗 Get the recipe

Sinfully Good Drinks

A striped mug filled with marshmallows and whipped cream is being drizzled with chocolate syrup against a dark background.

Chocolate Martini

Creamy, boozy, and deliciously decadent, perfect for sipping while sleuthing.

Red Wine with Chocolate Notes

Pick a bottle known for its cocoa undertones to bring out the best in your entrée and your mystery.

Chocolate Old Fashioned

A dark twist on the classic cocktail, with bourbon, chocolate bitters, and a chocolate-covered cherry.

Decadent Hot Chocolate

Wrap up the night with a rich cup of cocoa, topped with whipped cream and shavings of your favorite chocolate bar.

Final Course: Intrigue & Indulgence

Your "Death by Chocolate" Valentine's Day murder mystery isn’t just a dinner, it’s an experience. With this rich, romantic, and slightly dangerous menu, you’ll set the scene for an unforgettable evening of passion, puzzles, and perfectly plated decadence. So light the candles, pour the wine, and get ready for a night of deliciously dark drama.