If you grew up in the late ‘90s or early 2000s, chances are your afternoons were shaped by one iconic show: MTV’s Total Request Live (TRL).

When we started building our latest 90s murder mystery game, we knew we didn’t want it to feel like a generic throwback. We wanted it to feel like stepping directly into a moment. Into the noise, the pressure, and the personalities that defined that era.

If you’re planning a 90s-themed party, hosting a murder mystery night, or just craving a serious dose of nostalgia, nothing sets the vibe quite like iconic 90s snacks. From Dunkaroos to Cosmic Brownies, here are the best 90s snack recipes you can recreate at home for your next party or throwback night.